Long Days and Short Years

just trying to pay attention so I don't miss my life

Did Mama Grinch Kill Santa Claus? You Decide.


And here we go again.  It all begins innocently enough.

Last year our youngest daughter learned two simple facts.  One.  Santa was modeled after St.Nicholas.  Two.  St. Nicholas lived a long time ago.

She started thinking.  Processing.  Her eyes grew wide as her brain made a logical leap.  Then the question came:

“Santa is died?”

“Uh, well, not exactly, but sort of, I mean…” (to see an account of my stammering, look here.)


The saga continues in 2013.


It’s our oldest this year, our lovely almost-six year old daughter.  Last week we attended a St. Nicholas party, during which my friend read the story of St. Nicholas to the assembled kids.  And then… what was that?… a knock on the door!  Outside there was a basket of adorable little stockings, filled with clementines and candy.  The kids bounced and screamed.

St. Nicholas! St. Nicholas!  It’s a miracle!

A Miracle!

But our oldest saw only candy canes.  She negotiated her sugar allowance (2 pieces) and ran upstairs.  A half hour later she cornered me in the kitchen.  “Mama?”  “Yes?”  “This is beginning to get creepy.”  “Creepy?”  “Yes.  They’re all upstairs saying that St. Nicholas brought us the stockings, but St. Nicholas is dead, Mama.  That’s creepy to say that he brought them.”


“Mama, I want you to tell me who really gave us the stockings.  Was it the grown-ups?”

“Yes,” I confessed.  She smiled widely.  “But you can’t tell any of the other kids, okay?”  “Okay, Mama.”

She bounced back upstairs.  My heart sunk a little.  She isn’t yet six.


When I was their age, I did believe in Santa, so much so that I swear I once heard reindeer hooves on my roof.  I brought my list to the mall, put out carrots and cookies on Christmas Eve, and wondered how he could do it, all in one night like that.  It was about more than just the presents, it was the story, and I was caught up in all of it.

The magic faded gradually as I grew.  I don’t remember a moment when the scales fell from my eyes, nor a strong sense of betrayal when I realized I had been duped.  Rather, my desire for the presents themselves slowly supplanted my need for reindeer and the North Pole.  Santa?  Yeah, right.  What I wanted were new jeans and a phone for my room.  My family continued to leave out carrots and cookies, but it was just for little brothers, and then just for tradition.  Cute.  It was a cute story for little kids, but really, I’m too old for all that.

And at some point I began to question all the cute stories.  Santa with reindeer, Baby Jesus in the manger.  December seemed to be a month for myths, and how different were a ‘he sees you when you’re sleeping’ Santa and a God looking down from above?  C’mon.  Let’s talk about my list, cause the pile of presents is magic enough for me.

And it was enough, until it wasn’t.

Once upon a time I became too old for stories, and later I became too old to live without them.  Somewhere around late high school, something changed.  The stuff wasn’t enough anymore.  But what do you do when you’re eighteen, and you can’t go back to Santa?  What do you do when you suspect that Jesus is just the grown-up’s version of flying reindeer?


It is possible that there could be true magical stories?


At our house there are four kids under the age of six and four parents (under the age of, um…) who are trying to give the kids a magical month of December.  We four adults have fallen into Christian communities in one way or another, with varying amounts of struggle along the way, and we have found our homes in a common story.

Now we are trying to give this away.

But it’s hard, because the animals around the manger don’t fly, and Jesus didn’t come to earth to give us I-Pads.    The Heifer International catalog has a lot more to do with Christmas than the Toys R’ Us advertisement, but really… what would you have wanted to look at when you were almost-six?  It’s hard to not feel like Religious Nut Mama Grinch when the American Girl catalog goes straight into the trash.


We have not given up on magic around here.  There are Christmas lights covering every surface of the porch, and a ‘yes, you can play with it’ manger scene.  Baby Jesus is getting a birthday cake (cause really, kids+sugar is a winning combination for any holiday), and kids in Haiti are getting new soccer balls (cause that’s what Jesus put on his list).  There are boots for St. Nicolas Day, secret gifts for St. Lucia Day, and (if I actually get around to it this year) cookies for the neighbors delivered with smiles and Santa hats.  And yes, there are presents on December 25th, and the grown-ups who gave them to you love you very much.

Sometimes I’m still not sure if we’re cheating them the magic of Santa and reindeer on the roof, but when it comes down to it, we’re just trying to give them magic that will last, magic that you can’t grow out of.

We’ll let you know how it went in a couple of decades.


3 thoughts on “Did Mama Grinch Kill Santa Claus? You Decide.

  1. I think you’re doing an amazing job! I never grew up believing in Santa… we opened presents Christmas Eve, so it just didn’t work, and my parents would always tell us about St. Nicholas, and that Santa was just pretend… And I never felt like I missed out on the magic of Christmas! Actually, growing up I always felt just the opposite, that I knew even more of the magic, that I knew the real story that others didn’t, that I didn’t know just the facade but that I knew the deeper meaning. And we’re doing the same with our kids, but I’ve been even more blunt and mean about it than you! 😉 (Not that you were mean at all!). From the time Ava was 6 months old (her first Christmas) when we’d walk past Santa, I’d tell her he was just pretend (definitely got a lot of dirty looks for that!). When she was 18 months I told her Santa make-believe like Dora. That year she was taught to say before opening every present, “God loves me. God gave me a present. God gave me Jesus.” Her first year in preschool (age 3 1/2 and her 4th Christmas) was knew all about God giving gifts because He loves us, us giving gifts to show God’s love to others, St. Nicholas who lived long ago who gave gifts to show God’s love, and Santa just a guy in a costume like you see in Disneyland. I got a little nervous about what she’d say. I told the preschool teacher that we ‘don’t do Santa’ (got the look), and told her I hoped my daughter wouldn’t tell her classmates… but those little ears hear really well when you don’t want them to, and my over-articulate oldest asked me at age 3 1/2, “Why, mommy? Why wouldn’t I tell my friends about Jesus and God loving them? Aren’t we supposed to tell everyone?” And right then and there I decided, she’s right. And I told her that. And other kids can choose to believe or not believe what she tells them. And other parents can get mad at me. I’m sure I’ll be mad at other parents later in life for the things their kids will tell my daughter about evolution or life is all about having fun. I’m going to teach my kids the truth, and I’m going to encourage them to tell anyone they want to about the truth, even if that truth is about Santa, and she tells it to 5 yr olds. Those 5 year olds can still choose to believe, but I want my daughter to know and be bold about the true miracle and magic in Christmas. So, Mama Grinch, your heart is 3 sizes too big because you love your girls too much to let them be deceived and you want them to know the deep wonder and truth! 😉 Merry Christmas!

  2. Correction… Kyle reminded me that it was her first year of preschool (age 3 1/2) we told her that she knew the “Big Girl Secret Truth.” It was when she her second year of preschool (age 4 1/2) that she heard me talking to her preschool teacher, and questioned me. =)

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s